I. Harriet's Contemporary Story & Her Connection to the Past:

• Personal History and Heritage: Harriet is in Paris and feels a profound connection to a dress displayed in a museum, recognizing it as part of her "shared histories" and "my own personal history." This sets up the central theme of exploring family history and legacy.


• Seeking Identity and Purpose: Harriet's move to Paris and her interest in fashion, despite her father's disapproval, suggest a desire to forge her own path and connect with her past. The encouragement from her grandmother Claire and her friends in a photograph fuels this journey.


• Uncertainty about Family Legacy: While drawn to her ancestors, Harriet harbors anxieties about their past, particularly her grandmother Claire's relationship with a German officer during the war, Ernst. She fears inheriting "shame and guilt" and questions the nature of her family's legacy.


• Impact of Mother's Depression: Harriet reflects on her mother's life and wonders if a difficult family legacy contributed to her "fragility" and the "depression that ultimately destroyed her." This suggests a deeper exploration of intergenerational trauma.


• Developing Relationships: Harriet is forming connections in Paris, notably with Simone, a colleague, and Thierry, with whom a romantic interest is blossoming. These relationships provide a contemporary backdrop and potential for support as she delves into her family history.


• Personal Growth and Finding Strength: Through learning about her grandmother's history, particularly her Breton roots and bravery during the war, Harriet begins to feel a sense of connection and strength within herself, overcoming feelings of inadequacy.


• Traumatic Event: A traumatic incident involving a speeding van and a terrorist plot leaves Harriet severely injured and in a coma. This event serves as a potential catalyst for deeper reflection and change.

II. Claire, Mireille, and Vivienne's Story During World War II:

• Life Under German Occupation in Paris (1940-1942): The excerpts vividly portray the daily realities of life in occupied Paris, including curfews, the presence of German soldiers, rationing (implied by scarce food and chocolate being a luxury), and the continuation of the fashion industry under special licenses.


• Resistance Activities: Mireille becomes involved in the French Resistance, undertaking tasks such as delivering messages and potentially sheltering individuals. This highlights the bravery and risks taken by ordinary citizens.


• Friendship and Support: Claire, Mireille, and Vivienne, who live and work together as seamstresses at Delavigne Couture, form a strong bond of friendship and offer each other support in difficult times.


• Moral Ambiguity and Complicated Relationships: Claire enters into a relationship with Ernst, a German officer, which creates tension and moral conflict, particularly with her brother Jean-Paul. This explores the complexities of survival and personal choices during wartime.


• Infiltration and Deception: Vivienne's character raises suspicion. While seemingly a friend, there are hints of a hidden agenda and potential connection to Monsieur Leroux, suggesting a more complex role within the wartime context.


• Deportation and Concentration Camps: Vivienne's later experiences in a concentration camp are revealed, highlighting the brutal realities faced by those deemed enemies of the Nazi regime. The descriptions of the triangles and her act of sabotage underscore the resilience and resistance within the camps.


• Loss and Capture: The arrest of Monsieur and Madame Arnaud, and later the capture of Claire and Vivienne by the Gestapo, demonstrate the constant danger faced by those involved in resistance activities.


• Acts of Defiance and Resilience: Despite the hardships, the women demonstrate acts of defiance, such as Vivienne's sabotage in the factory and Claire's courageous stand against Ernst. Their resilience in the face of oppression is a central theme.

III. Parallels and Connections Between the Narratives:

• Fashion as a Backdrop: The world of haute couture serves as a common thread connecting the two timelines. For Harriet, it's a career and a link to her grandmother's past; for Claire, Mireille, and Vivienne, it's their profession and a part of the fabric of their lives in occupied Paris.


• Themes of Identity and Legacy: Both narratives explore the characters' search for identity and grapple with the weight of family history and personal choices.


• Courage and Resilience: The stories of Claire, Mireille, and Vivienne highlight their courage and resilience in the face of war, qualities that Harriet seems to be discovering within herself through their story.


• Impact of the Past on the Present: Harriet's emotional reactions to her grandmother's story and the echoes of past trauma in her nightmares demonstrate how the events of the war continue to impact subsequent generations.

欢迎大家留言分享你的感想，或者加艾薇同学的微信加入我们的听友群参与讨论～